The best I can say about this film is that it had some excellent shots. But, well…
How can I word this? There are a certain number of things wrong with this film. 1) Jilted camera angles and movements. 2) Overacting on the part of 2/3 of the cast. 3) A Been-There, Done-That Storyline.
If I tried really hard, I’m sure I could make the list grow, but the film really isn’t worth my time.
The story is Anna Holtz, a charming 23-year-old musician-to-be who has been sent from her conservatory to do some work under Beethoven. Of course, Beethoven in a rude brute who no one understands, except for OMG Anna! How tremendously convenient that the only person who can understand Beethoven came in time to be his copyist before the Ninth Symphony is performed on Sunday.
In between being snarled at and having zen conversations about music and God, Karl, B’s nephew, drops by and is a rude, spoiled brat looking for some money to waste gambling. Of course, even though he looks like some heroin addict, Karl is actually a very sympathetic character, because he doesn’t want to play the piano! O, woe is he for having an uncle who adores him like a son. Then he runs away, to return to further his weasely ways.
Anna is staying at her great aunt’s convent while she’s in Vienna and is encouraged to drop her silly dreams of becoming a composer, because girls can’t become composers, silly. Her aunt, the Mother Superior, tells her that dreams are dangerous, but beautiful, and that she once had the dream to study under Salieri. Let me tell you, that explains a lot about Anna’s aunt and her taste in music.
So, Vienna is agog at Beethoven and his 2-hour long symphony and the fact that he wants to conduct (But he’s deaf! Vienna shouts). And Martin Bauer, the beau of Anna, is the most annoying person in this entire movie. He is an engineer of the future and has really, really awful lines about building bridges to the future. As far as I can throw him, he’s all that’s bad about the industrial era in a nut shell for this movie.
But Anna, o she loves him. She thinks. Well, the chemistry ain’t that great, but it’s a helluva lot better than that shit from the Star Wars prequels, is all I can say. While Martin works on his bridge, he has a tangent about how no one listens to Beethoven anymore, blah di blah.
Then, the symphony! Only Karl’s not there, so Beethoven can’t compose. Not unless Anna’s onstage with him, composing from the orchestra. So they do and it takes up a lot of time. Probably the best use of time in this entire film, but only for the music. There’s a montage in here that will make an epiliptic seizure and a lot of close ups of Beethoven cutting to Anna cutting to Beethoven cutting to Chorus cutting to Beethoven cutting to audience cutting to orchestra cutting to Anna cutting to Beethoven cutting to WTF Karl? Who looks even more like a heroin addict now than every before! Then he disappears and everything is apparently resolved in that area of the world. Meanwhile, the standing ovation scene is a complete rip off from Immortal Beloved.
After the Ninth Symphony scene, everything is about God from here on out. Beethoven whines to Anna about God, Anna says nothing. Beethoven is the Zen Master of Music: The Language of God. Anna tries her hand at composing. Beethoven works on his new Quartets. Anna questions God because Beethoven makes fun of her composition. Mother Superior tells her that she would be safe in the convent, away from all of that dirty, dirty Viennese trash and deaf composers. Then Beethoven begs for forgiveness and we’re back on the religious track! Yippee.
Martin presents his bridge design for a contest and Beethoven just comes by and smashes it with his cane. The design was the basic iron bridge design, nothing really special anyway. Anna and Martin break up, because they can’t really stand eachother. Anna turns to Beethoven for yelling matches and… more talk about God. Then he asks her to bathe him. (You think I’m joking, but I’m not).
No one understands Beethoven’s new quartets, which is a pity because they’re rather nice. Then he collapses and Anna nurses him back to health. He goes to sleep and when he wakes up, he has a new idea for a song. Anna dictates while he sits in bed, and this scene totally isn’t a rip off of Amadeus, why do you ask?
One final conversation about God and Music and END MOVIE!
Copying Beethoven has a maturity level somewhere under Beethoven Lives Upstairs. I can’t even sit lose myself to the pretty landscape or to the costumes because Vienna is portrayed as bland and dismal while the costumes are drab in greys and browns, except for an occassional blue. The direction isn’t my taste when it comes to a historical film. Lots of cuts and jags and Seizure-inducing montages. The film isn’t about Beethoven really, or about his music. It’s about Anna, which wouldn’t be so bad if she wasn’t such a Mary Sue. She’s entirely too boring, even in her costumes.
The easiest portrayal I can say is that this is Beethoven for the Religious, or for those who want to create an idea of Beethoven as being religious. Maybe he was, maybe he wasn’t. In the books I’ve read, he’s neither one way nor the other, but spiritually searching, always. To some, I’m sure this speaks volumes, but I look more towards other aspects of a historical figure’s character. With Beethoven, I want to see the Romanticism through him or the tortured individual, but Copying Beethoven delivered neither.